Take heed to this text

The prolonged attain of the UR10e cobot, which is top-mounted on a gantry, means it might trim two elements per setup, reducing trimming time practically in half in comparison with earlier guide trimming. | Credit score: Common Robots

Thermoforming, a know-how that’s greater than a century outdated, makes use of sheet plastic that’s heated to change into comfortable so it may be vacuum-formed in or round a mildew. Extra plastic is then reduce off to create ultimate merchandise with dimensions that vary from just a few inches to the scale of a room.

Through the years, 5-axis CNC routers changed hand-trimming for many thermoformers. Extra just lately, Juliet Oehler Goff, president and CEO of Los Angeles-based Kal Plastics, had watched her friends discover using massive industrial robots to finish-trim molded plastic elements, however she wasn’t satisfied. For a enterprise like hers, the preliminary worth level of business robots and their required security caging was too excessive, to not point out the programming prices.

“You find yourself having to have a skillset beneath your roof that’s very costly. That’s a danger for a small enterprise,” she mentioned. After speaking to colleagues, she heard behind the scenes that a lot of those that had tried industrial robots discovered that they didn’t work nicely for his or her functions and that they wouldn’t purchase them once more.

Analysis results in enterprise outcomes

Goff can be a director and member of the R&D committee for the nationwide trade affiliation, the Society of Plastics Engineers (SPE) Thermoforming Division. In that function, she had been concerned in quite a few discussions in regards to the state of robotics, notably collaborative robotics, and their utility within the trade.

When Kal Plastics wanted to interchange a CNC machine that was nearing the top of its life, Goff was introduced with a possibility. She got down to analysis using cobots for her personal enterprise and agreed to share her findings on the group’s nationwide convention.

As a contract producer, Kal Plastics produces a variety of elements with various complexity and tolerances. Goff regarded for low-hanging fruit for the preliminary cobot deployment: elements that introduced security or productiveness points with hand-trimming and could possibly be produced on less-expensive gear to spice up competitiveness. As soon as she may show the cobot labored, she knew there have been different jobs that match these standards.

“I did my homework and located that Common Robots was the worldwide chief within the collaborative robotic house,” Goff mentioned. “They got here out and gave us an illustration, and once I regarded on the numbers, they had been actually enticing. I used to be taking a look at getting one other five-axis CNC router, and on the time it could have been a $250,000 funding and I’d have waited 12 months to take supply. After I met with UR, I used to be quoted two weeks to get the gear, and the entry level was 1 / 4 or a fifth of the associated fee.”

Through the course of her analysis, Goff employed Dan Sproles, a marketing consultant and one other director for SPE Thermoforming, to assist enhance total operations. Since his preliminary skepticism, Sproles has additionally change into a champion of light-weight, cost-effective, and easy-to-program UR cobots.

“In case you’re a thermoformer that’s been in enterprise for 50 years or 5 months, if I have a look at the cobot, it’s an ideal match—as a result of I can’t afford a brand new CNC, however I can afford this,” Sproles mentioned. “And I can afford somebody who’s going to mainly take a pill and program it. So your bang on your buck—it’s the robotic.”

“It could be silly for different processors to not think about including this to their operation,” Goff concurred. “They’d be actually lacking out on a sensible enterprise choice.”

Kal Plastics CEO Juliet Oehler Goff watches as robotic operator José Luis packages the UR10e cobot to trim thermoformed plastic elements. | Credit score: Common Robots

Contained in the cobot cell

Previous to putting in the UR10e collaborative robotic, the forming and tough trimming passed off within the thermoforming cell, after which the elements needed to be transferred to the CNC router in one other a part of the plant. The Kal Plastics facility is housed in a number of older buildings, so transferring elements was disruptive and added manufacturing time. It additionally introduced alternatives for injury or security hazards as elements stacked up ready in queues.

The preliminary job recognized for the cobot is a fancy trim of a four-cavity mildew, through which one sheet of plastic is shaped into 4 elements. The flexibility to put in the cobot into the identical work cell alongside the thermoformer impressed Sproles to explain it as a “cell manufacturing dream.” Shaped elements come off the thermoformer and are instantly rough-cut to separate them. They’re then delivered on to the cobot, which might trim two items in every setup. The cobot takes practically half the time of hand-trimming and supplies better accuracy and consistency.

The deployment has two routers mounted on the robotic arm—one with an ordinary router bit and one with a bigger noticed blade. The benefit is that the routers are the identical industrial instruments used for hand trimming. They’re cheap and out there off-the-shelf at any ironmongery store, so there isn’t any costly substitute or downtime resulting from tooling points. Balancing the 2 heavy routers as they rotated across the half introduced early challenges that had been solved by mounting the robotic arm overhead on a gantry to scale back stress on the robotic joints and enhance accuracy.

The effectivity of the brand new work cell has already paid off. “The robotic has mainly taken over the entire overflow that we needed to do by hand,” Sproles defined. “Previously, we at all times needed to juggle backwards and forwards on the CNCs simply to make supply dates. We launched the cobot: now there’s no extra additional time and we are able to ship on time. I’d say late shipments have dropped to lower than one p.c.”

Now that the cobot has been confirmed, Goff is wanting ahead to implementing newer, bigger cobots in different workstations, and for processes past trimming. In the end, she would like to “kind, trim, palletize, out-the-door” from full, automated work cells. Till then, the pliability of the comparatively light-weight cobot is an added bonus. Not like a CNC, which requires a big devoted house, everlasting set up, and a three-phase, 480V energy supply, the gantry and UR10e cobot together with the fixture desk may be moved anyplace within the plant as wanted, so long as there’s a customary 110V energy outlet.

Decreasing prices and dangers

The cobot’s ease of programming was an enormous deal, mentioned Sproles. “If I purchased a daily CNC, common robotic, I’m going to spend hundreds of {dollars} coaching that particular person, not understanding in the event that they’re going to be right here tomorrow.”

The expense and danger of coaching employees in conventional programming are important for small companies, that are already dealing with difficulties retaining expert employees in a aggressive labor surroundings. With the UR cobot, José Luis, a Kal Plastics operator, discovered the fundamentals of programming utilizing the free on-line UR Academy lessons, which he may entry in his native Spanish. He then attended two periods of inexpensive, hands-on coaching. That was all it took for him to have the ability to create new packages, change instruments, and make changes as wanted.

Luis acknowledges that know-how is evolving and his previous abilities is not going to essentially be the abilities he wants sooner or later, so he’s anticipating the chance to study. He mentioned, “My job is extra fascinating as a result of the manufacturing course of has actually improved, and the robotic supplies me with a safer office.”

Goff is thrilled to have a approach to retain and advance her valued staff. “It will get your workforce excited as a result of it’s completely different, it’s cool, it’s distinctive,” she mentioned. “Whenever you get somebody who’s youthful, who’s hungry, you wish to discover a approach to fulfill their starvation and preserve them and motivated.” She added, “It’s been a deal with to observe José develop on this function, and elevate himself.”

Luis is already scheduled for a grasp programmer class, the place Sproles expects he’ll acquire extra perception to make the robotic cell much more worthwhile and repeatable, and to program it for any new jobs the corporate brings in.

Kal Plastics balanced two industrial routers on the UR10e cobot arm, utilizing a noticed blade and an ordinary router. | Credit score: Common Robots

Necessity is the mom of invention

Goff described California as a troublesome state for manufacturing. Challenges embody excessive prices of labor, occupancy, and power, in addition to a regulatory surroundings that presents extra workforce challenges.

“It’s a no-fault state for employees’ compensation accidents,” she defined. “It’s the fitting factor to supply a protected office surroundings, but it surely’s additionally a fiduciary duty to attempt to keep away from having these incidents happen. So we’re at all times in search of methods to work safer, work smarter, work quicker.”

Together with these challenges, Goff can be coping with labor points which are widespread throughout the nation: employees who’re much less thinking about manufacturing jobs. Labor and security had been key drivers for Kal Plastics to change into an early automation adopter. “Necessity is the mom of invention,” Goff acknowledged.

The job the UR cobot now handles was once hand-trimmed. Sproles mentioned, “On this plant, there are two folks that may route elements. So in the event you introduced in a job that needed to be hand-routed, you’ve bought these two folks and also you’re locked in as a result of that’s all they’ll do.” Now these staff may be redeployed to safer, extra worthwhile duties, and manufacturing isn’t restricted to the supply of these employees, giving the corporate higher manufacturing flexibility.

When Goff started her analysis, her workforce was afraid robots had been going to interchange their jobs. She advised them, “Hear, you don’t get it, guys. I would like you to be protected. I would like you to work sensible. I don’t need you to only depend on your palms; I would like you to depend on your data and abilities. If we are able to get our work surroundings to some extent the place you’re extra of a QC operator than a machine operator, that’s a win for everyone.”
After working with the cobot, her employees’ attitudes have utterly modified. Goff mentioned, “As soon as everybody settled down they usually noticed how this factor labored, it was like, ‘Why didn’t we do that sooner?’”